Seagate castle, Irvine
Maryborough salt pan houses
weavers' cottages in Crosshill

Articles

Culzean coach house
Return to Home page Go to About page Go to list of Articles Go to Bibliography Go to Links page Go to illustrated catalogue of Ayrshire milestones Go to Research Postings Search this site

Copyright notice:  Links to this site are welcomed.  However none of the material on the site may be duplicated in any form.  The copyright of the articles is the property of the authors.  Copyright of the web pages is the property of David McClure.

James McAdam: Waterhead to Whitefoord
by David Courtney McClure

This article was first published in Ayrshire Notes 31 (2006), 4-9.

James McAdam of Waterhead (c.1716-1770), father of John Loudon McAdam, built Lagwine (also 'Lagwyne') 'castle' at Carsphairn, resided for a time in Ayr - reputedly at the time of John Loudon's birth - and died at Whitefoord House. This much is generally accepted. Through a study of window tax records [WTR], these movements have been traced and his periods in residence at his various houses identified within the limits of the six or twelve month taxation periods.

The ruins of Lagwine, March 2006. photo David Courtney McClure

Window tax was first levied in Scotland under an Act of 1746 for taxation of 'Houses, Windows or Lights'. [1] The annual charge on a house with 10 to 14 windows was 6d for every window; with 15 to 10 windows it was 9d; and with more than 20 windows it was 1s. Thus for 14 windows the tax due was 14 x 6d or 7s; for 15 windows it was 15 x 9d or 11s 3d. Where there were fewer than 10 windows a house tax of 2s was payable, but houses in Scotland were exempt. In 1757 this exemption was restricted to houses with no more than 5 windows or lights, and house tax was reduced to 1s; houses with 6, 7, 8, or 9 windows were liable to house tax of 1s. [2] However in 1761 window tax was extended to houses with 7, 8, or 9 windows: up to 5 windows no tax was payable. with 6 windows house tax of 1s was payable; and with 7 or more windows, window tax. [3] An act of 1778 exempted houses worth less than 5 a year, or 10 in the case of farmhouses. [4] The charging periods appear in some cases as Whitsunday (15th May) to Martinmas (11th November) and Martinmas to Whitsunday, in others as May to November and November to May. At other times a period of a year is recorded, Whitsunday to Whitsunday or May to May. [5]

The tax was payable by occupiers rather than owners, and this is the particular advantage of the WTR. In May to November 1753, the first period for which complete WTR have survived, James McAdam occupied a house of 44 windows in the parish of Ochiltree, described in the WTR as 'Lord Glencairn's house'; such identification of an owner is uncommon. Ochiltree House, the mansion house of the estate, was by far the largest of the four houses in the parish liable for tax (the number of windows being taken as an index of size). It was jointly with Kirkmichael House the 24th largest in Ayrshire at the time. McAdam's wife Susannah, as granddaughter of Sir John Cochrane of Ochiltree, had a strong family connection with the house. The first earl of Dundonald had given the estate of Ochiltree, comprising about three fifths of the parish, to his second son, also Sir John Cochrane. However in 1737, Charles Cochrane sold it to James Macrae, a former governor of Madras. Macrae, who had no family of his own, had become the benefactor of the family of a cousin who had married Hugh McGuire, and he settled the estate on their daughter Elizabeth on her marriage in 1744 to William, thirteenth earl of Glencairn. [6]

By 1797-1798 Ochiltree House (NS 510 212) was apparently absent from the WTR, but the 14-windowed house occupied by the Rev. Thomson was probably the habitable portion of the larger edifice. He described it as 'an old mansion house, situated at the east end of the village of Ochiltree, which is the present residence of the minister, the manse being entirely in ruins.' [7] By 1856 the house had been derelict for many years: 'Ochiltree House, the property of the dowager Lady Boswell, is a plain building, three storeys high, with crow-stepped gables and a slate roof. It is in bad repair and becoming ruinous. Attached to and occupying the E front of the mansion is a ruin, about 12ft high, divided into apartments. Its walls are about 6ft thick and part of an arched roof is still entire. It has the appearance of having been a castle of some strength. It must have been unoccupied for a long time as there are large trees growing within it.' [8] The house was brought back into habitation later. There are records of additions to the building in 1891, possibly for James Angus, coalmaster and elder brother of Robert Angus of Ladykirk. [9] He was the occupier c.1900 and until his death in 1902.

Alexander Murdoch in 1921 called it the 'Big House', standing 'in a delightful situation at the junction of the Lugar and the Burnoch'. He continued,

Though the building is tall and plain-looking, with narrow windows and pointed gables, its architectural defects are fully compensated for by the beauty of its situation at the meeting of the waters.

The present structure is over two hundred years old. It was erected on the site of a still more ancient edifice, whose foundation walls can even yet be traced. Within the recollection of some of the older people of the village, a wing of the former castle protruded at right angles from the south side of the present house, and with its massive, ivy-covered walls and attenuated, broad-arrow windows formed a characteristic relic of the troubled times when every house of any importance had to be built after the fashion of a fortress. [10]

Ochiltree House [*] was pulled down in 1952. [11] It was reported in 1981 that the site had been completely cleared, and was occupied by a road and by a new 'Ochiltree House'. [12]

In November 1753 to May 1754, and May 1754 to May 1755 McAdam continued in Ochiltree parish. but in a house with 18 windows. Glencairn's house was 'not inhabited', and thus no tax was due on it. The last period for which McAdam is found in the Ochiltree WTR is Whitsunday to Martinmas 1755, for which his name appears as occupier against the house of 18 windows, but it was 'not uninhabited'.

But what of Waterhead? McAdam's barony of Waterhead was in the Kirkcudbrightshire parish of Carsphairn. There was no entry for a house of that name in the WTR for Whitsunday to Martinmas 1753, when three dwellings in the parish were taxed, nor in any subsequent period. [13] This indicates a house of no more than 9 windows. Waterhead was a mean dwelling compared to McAdam's Ochiltree homes. It was also very remote, lying about 3 miles north of Carsphairn beside the Water of Deugh. McAdam's new house of Lagwine, just over half a mile from Carsphairn church and on the rutted unmade road from Dalmellington, appeared first in the WTR in Martinmas 1754 to Whitsunday 1755. It was recorded as having 13 windows and being 'not finished'. In subsequent periods it was 'not inhabited'. McAdam was not liable for tax there until Whitsunday to Martinmas 1757.

From May 1755, when he left Ochiltree, until Whitsunday 1757, when he occupied Lagwine, McAdam could have been residing at Waterhead, and not troubling the tax records. He was, however, occupying a house of 17 windows in Ayr. [14] He was there first in May 1755 to May 1756 and remained until May 1759 to Whitsunday 1760. John Loudon was born on 23rd September 1756, during McAdam's time in Ayr and when Lagwine was 'not inhabited'.

The house McAdam occupied in Ayr has been identified, possibly only by tradition, as 'Lady Cathcart's house' in Sandgate, though there is ambiguity over the identity of the lady in question. According to the plaque on the building, the house was owned by Lord Elias Cathcart, and it is named after his widow. [15] However, there was no 'Lord Elias Cathcart'. Charles Schaw Cathcart (1721-1771) succeeded as ninth earl of Cathcart in 1740, and was the sole Lord Cathcart at that time. The earls of Cathcart were significant landowners in Ayrshire, their estates including Sundrum and Auchencruive. With the disposal of the latter to Richard Oswald in 1764, Schaw Park in Clackmannan became the family seat. In May 1755 Charles Cathcart was the owner of an uninhabited 18-windowed house in Ayr. Another 18-windowed house was occupied by Baillie Cathcart: i.e. Elias Cathcart, a tobacco and wine merchant, who was admitted a burgess and guild brother of the Royal Burgh in 1733, and served as provost in 1757-1759. [16] James McAdam is listed separately as the occupier of a house with 17 windows. Thus he lived neither in the house then occupied by Elias Cathcart, nor in the uninhabited house belonging to Lord Charles Cathcart, though since the owner of the house he did occupy is not recorded, it could well have been the property of either of them, or, indeed, it could have belonged to someone else entirely.

As to 'Lady Cathcart', it may be noted that the widows of untitled landowners were frequently termed 'Lady'. Georgina Keith McAdam, daughter of John Loudon McAdam, later recorded that 'Great Grandmama was a very stately lady and never gave up her title of Lady Waterhead', a dignity rather than title arising from the barony of Waterhead. [17] The 1755 WTR show that Ladies Brownhill, Trochrige, Achenskeith, and Dunduff, none of them the widows of lords, baronets, or knights, were also then occupants of houses in Ayr. Elias Cathcart acquired a small estate in Alloway; this, and his important position in the burgh, appears to justify his widow's courtesy title.

Lagwine proved to be a short-lived venture. [18] For the year Whitsunday 1757 until Whitsunday 1758 he was liable for tax on 13 windows. In the following period, Whitsunday to Martinmas 1758, the record shows 8 windows and only house tax was levied. A window could be discounted for tax only if it were 'stopped up', which required it to be filled with stone or brick, or plaster or lath, or with the same materials as on the outside of the house. Just a year after entering his new 'castle' at Carsphairn, McAdam had taken steps to reduce its size or to stop up 5 of its windows. Until Whitsunday 1760 he was also paying tax on his house in Ayr. He continued paying house tax on Lagwine until Whitsunday 1763, following which it disappeared from the records, having been destroyed by fire in December 1762.

In September 1762, James Boswell visited Lagwine, being a cousin of James McAdam's wife, and played with the children, one of them the six-year-old John Loudon. Three months later Boswell's tutor, William McQuhae, wrote to advise him that

the house at Lagwine, which afforded you a hospitable retreat on your road to Galloway was burned to ashes about ten days ago. With great difficulty the children's lives were preserved by their leaping naked out of windows two storeys high. Not a single paper nor piece of furniture could be saved from the flames. It is a prodigious loss to the worthy gentleman, particularly as his bills and rights of his estate are all destroyed. [19]

D.S. Ramsay, the nephew of General Sir John Shaw Kennedy, himself a nephew of John Loudon McAdam, recorded the fire in a memoir dated 1883, in which he makes John Loudon rather younger than his six years. [20]

While still in the cradle, [John Loudon McAdam's] father and mother, going on a visit to Edinburgh left him at their house of Lagwyne, parish of Carsphairn, in charge of his elder sisters and a nurse. During the parental absence the house took fire as evil chance would have it, in the middle of a winter night, the flames gaining so rapidly that the family had to seek refuge (some of them in their night-dresses), on the bleak hill side covered with snow. While from this unenviable position they stood helplessly gazing at their house enveloped in smoke and flame, it was observed with horror that the little one in the cradle had been forgotten. The nurse crying out "Am I going to add murder to arson" (it seemed her carelessness had been the cause of the fire), rushed back and at considerable risk to herself, saved her charge from the flames. To reach the nearest place of shelter, the party now homeless wanderers, carrying Loudon in their arms, had to make their way as best they could on foot, over half a mile of dreary upland rendered still more desolate by snow and darkness. After a weary tramp and much suffering they reached at last the manse of Carsphairn, where they were hospitably received by the good minister.

McAdam did not rebuild Lagwine, and his whereabouts for over a year until Whitsunday 1764 are not recorded. It is then that the WTR first show his occupation of the 35-windowed house in Straiton parish belonging to Sir John Whitefoord of Whitefoord. The house was named 'Blaehane' in the WTR for 1756, but was later given the name of Whitefoord, under which the estate is depicted on the Armstrongs' 1775 Map of Ayrshire. [21] There is an engraving belonging to the estate entitled 'The Old Castle of Blairquhan - 1787; given that the date is 12 years before the sale, it is surprising that it is named 'Blairquhan' rather than 'Whitefoord'. According to Davis, the castle 'formed a complex of considerable size and magnificence'; it was much grander than McAdam's circumstances warranted. [22] Sir John sold the estate in 1798 to Sir David Hunter Blair, under whom it reverted to a form of its earlier name, Blairquhan. He had a new mansion erected in 1820-1824, in which only a few details of the former building have been retained. [23]

James McAdam remained at Whitefoord until his death on 20th August 1770. [24] A. Cochrane, the niece of his widow Susannah, wrote of the circumstances of his passing to her brother in December:

I was also at my Uncle McAdam's sometime, who then resided at Whitefoord & [He] was very ill of the Gout, which ended in a Dropsy and at last cut him off about three months ago. He was generally thought an Extravagant Man, and from that 'twas apprehended his circumstances might be embarrassed. But it turned out otherwise at his death, for fortunately for my Aunt & 5 [sic] daughters he has left unmarried he died worth about 6 or 7000 & to each of the girls he left 500 the rest to his only Son Loudon a promising boy yet at school. [25]

Whitefoord Castle (The Old Castle of Blairquhan, 1787)
reproduced from the Blairquhan guidebook by permission of Patrick Hunter Blair.

It might have been speculated that the elimination of windows at Lagwine, thus reducing the tax liability, was an economy measure. His reputation however, and the grand houses he occupied in Ochiltree and Straiton, suggest that there may have been another cause.

During his decline McAdam sold his Waterhead estate to the earl of Stair. [26] John McAdam of Craigengillan, a distant relation but a close associate, acted for him in the business. Craigengillan's intentions may not have been honourable: a few years later he purchased the estate from the earl, a matter which gave rise to considerable resentment on the part of the Waterhead McAdams, who felt that they had been cheated out of their inheritance.

David McClure


[*] Postscript concerning Ochiltree House

I had the following notes on file but did not remember them until after publication:
1) NLS Catalogue of Scottish Postcards: Pc.8/A101, 'Ochiltree House, where John Knox was married.'
2) Shaw (1953), 55: 'is in the course of being demolished.'


[1] 20 Geo. II c.3, 1746, National debt.

[2] 31 Geo. II c.22, 1757, Pension duties.

[3] 2 Geo. III c.8, 1761, Window duties.

[4] 18 Geo. III c.26, 1778, House duty.

[5] National Archives of Scotland [NAS], Window Tax records for Ayrshire:
E326/1/11, May 1753-May 1759
E326/1/12, May 1759-May 1764 (May-November 1763 wanting)
E326/1/13, May 1764-April 1773
E326/1/14, April 1773-April 1782
E326/1/15, April 1782-April 1789
E326/1/16, April 1789-April 1798 (April 1795-April 1797 wanting).

[6] The Scots Peerage, vol. IV (Edinburgh, 1907), 250-252; Alexander Murdoch, Ochiltree: Its History and Reminiscences (Paisley, 1921), 74-79.

[7] Old Statistical Account (1791-1799), vol. V, Rev. William Thomson, Ochiltree, 448.

[8] Ordnance Survey Name Book, 1856.

[9] Information from Rob Close: Building Industries, Vol 1, no 12, March 1891, and Vol 2, no.1, April 1891, also Ayr Advertiser 19 February 1891; also the notes on James Angus.

[10] Murdoch, Ochiltree, 47-48.

[11] Information from Rob Close.

[12] Information from RCAHMS database.

[13] NAS, Window Tax records for Kirkcudbrightshire, E326/1/59-60.

[14] NAS, Window Tax records for Ayr: E326/1/134, March 1748-September 1748, May 1760-April 1798 (May 1753-May 1760 see vols. 11 and 12; April 1784-April 1785 see vol. 217; April 1795-April 1797 wanting).

[15] The full text of the plaque is: 'Lady Cathcart's House. One of the oldest secular buildings in the medieval Royal Burgh and now among the rarest in Scotland, it was remodelled in the 18th century, when it is said to have been owned by Lord Elias Cathcart after whose wife it is named. John Loudon Macadam [sic], the famous road engineer, was born here in 1756. For a few years in the 1850s it was the Ayr branch of the City of Glasgow Bank which failed in 1878. The building was purchased by the Bank of Scotland in the 1980s. In 1988, Kyle and Carrick Civic Society campaigned to save the building from demolition. The Bank of Scotland then generously donated Lady Cathcart's house to the Scottish Historic Buildings Trust and extensive repairs, principally funded by Historic Scotland, Enterprise Ayrshire, South Ayrshire Council and the Civic Society were completed in 1996.'

[16] Alistair Lindsay and Jean Kennedy, eds., The Burgesses and Guild Brethren of Ayr 1647-1846 (Ayrshire Federation of Historical Societies, 2002), 126; John Strawhorn, The History of Ayr: Royal Burgh and County Town (Edinburgh, 1989), 115, 284.

[17] Georgina Keith McAdam, 'The History of the Waterhead McAdams and the McAdams of Craigengillan'. (unpublished manuscript, 1854).

[18] An investigation and partial excavation of the ruins is reported by Alastair M.T. Maxwell-Irving, 'Lagwyne Castle (NX 558 939)', in Transactions of the Dumfriesshire and Galloway Natural History and Antiquarian Society, Third Series Vol. LXXI (Dumfries, 1996), 163-165.

[19] This letter dated 27th December 1762 is cited in Frederick A. Pottle, ed., Boswell's London Journal, 1762-1763 (Yale, 1950), editor's note to entry for 14-15th September 1762.

[20] Mgr D.S. Ramsay, 'Biographical Sketches of some Ayrshire people of the last and present centuries', 1883, 59-60; unpublished manuscript in Carnegie Library, Ayr (South Ayrshire Libraries).

[21] Captain Armstrong and Son, A New Map of Ayrshire, comprehending Kyle, Cunningham, & Carrick (1775).

[22] Michael C. Davis, The Castles and Mansions of Ayrshire (Ardrishaig, 1991), 181.

[23] Rob Close, Ayrshire & Arran: An Illustrated Architectural Guide (RIAS 1992), 188-189.

[24] Scots Magazine, XXXII (1770), 458.

[25] 'A. Cochrane', Castle Canon, to her brother [name unknown], 1st December 1770, Shaw Kennedy MSS., cited by Spiro, 'John Loudon McAdam'. McAdam actually had 7 unmarried sisters at the time.

[26] An account of this will be given in a subsequent article.

 

back to top
Return to Home page Go to About page Go to list of Articles Go to Bibliography Go to Links page Go to illustrated catalogue of Ayrshire milestones Go to Research Postings Search this site